COMPANIES IN FOCUSIn reports and research lists
THE SICPA FILEREPORT

Philippe Amon, are SICPA’s coffers in Türkiye being drained?

1.83 billion lira in three years. Three suppliers using the same telephone number. And 200,000 earphones, invoiced at 269 lira apiece. Under the reported revenue split, the company’s share of each audio-guide sale would be 19 lira.

Share this report
Dollar bills spill from an open safe between portraits of Sami Çebi and Philippe Amon. Payment records and an earpiece lie on the table.
Sami Çebi and Philippe Amon flank an open safe with dollar bills spilling out over payment records. AI-generated editorial illustration. · SICPA Türkiye · Sami Çebi · SICPA · Philippe Amon · © Elad Malka — The Ledgers

Investigation teaser

Open video

The Ledgers investigation teaser. The video is in English.

Payment lists and invoices show that SICPA’s Turkish company is making purchases worth millions of dollars from suppliers connected to one another. On the figures in the records we obtained and the tender documents, at least one of those purchases works out at a loss. The amount invoiced for 200,000 earphones is 14 times the company’s share of the revenue it would earn from the service they are used for.

The company won the contract to operate museum ticket offices in 2018. In payment lists for 2024–2026 attributed to the company, three groups of recipients account for 1.83 billion lira, or about $45 million at the August 2025 exchange rate. The lists record 1.22 billion lira for Kultura, 338 million for Mavi Uçak and 271 million for three suppliers that use the same telephone number.

The easiest item to check comes from the smallest of those groups. Caserta Global, one of the three suppliers, issued two invoices to SICPA Türkiye in August and September 2025 for 200,000 earphones, totalling about 53.7 million lira, or $1.3 million at the August 2025 rate. The average price per earphone was 269 lira, about $6.50.

The state sets the price of the service for which the earphones are used. The Ministry of Culture and Tourism’s fee schedule puts the average price of an audio guide at 113 lira. According to information obtained by The Ledgers, 83% of the revenue goes to the ministry’s revolving fund. SICPA Türkiye keeps 17%, or 19 lira. A 269-lira earphone for a 19-lira share of the sale. On that calculation, the invoices for those two months alone imply a shortfall of about 50 million lira, or $1.2 million.

Chinese sellers’ wholesale listings generally put disposable wired earphones and wired earphones for tour-guide systems at between $0.11 and $1.40 each. Even at the listed price of $1.40 for a tour-guide earphone, 200,000 would cost about 11.5 million lira. The invoiced amount is 4.7 times as much.

Caserta Global’s two shareholders also hold stakes in LZK Grup, which uses the same telephone number. LZK was incorporated in the week that 2025 began. It billed SICPA Türkiye for boat rental.

SICPA sells trust. Banknote ink, the code on a cigarette packet, a tax stamp: these are its business. Its message to customers comes down to one sentence. In our system, nothing goes missing. Türkiye was one of the first two countries to buy that system.

On 27 April 2023, the Office of the Attorney General of Switzerland convicted the same company in a corruption case and ordered it to pay 81 million Swiss francs. SICPA did not contest the decision and said it had put a robust compliance management system in place.

The lists we have are not a court ruling. On their own they do not establish any wrongdoing. But read together, they point to a question: are SICPA’s coffers in Türkiye being drained? Can its Swiss headquarters see what is happening? If it can, is it acting deliberately?

A 19-lira share of the sale, a 269-lira earphone

The invoiced price is clear. About 53.7 million lira for 200,000 earphones works out at an average of 268.5 lira each.

The price of the service is known, too. The Ministry of Culture and Tourism’s fee schedule effective 1 March 2024 lists audio-guide prices at 45 museums and archaeological sites. The lowest is 65 lira, the highest 200 and the price at Aspendos 120. The 44 prices quoted in lira average 113 lira, including VAT. In the schedule due to take effect on 1 April 2027, the highest price is 220 lira. The invoices were issued in August and September 2025, between those two dates.

SICPA Türkiye won a nine-year contract to operate museum ticket offices in the 2018 tender. According to the Turkish Revenue Administration’s 2018 tax ruling on that tender, the operator pays the portion of ticket revenue set out in the specifications to the ministry’s revolving fund (DÖSİMM) as the “administration’s share”. Information obtained by The Ledgers puts that share at 83%, leaving 17% for the company.

Here is how the figures work out.

ItemCalculationResult
Average audio-guide feeAverage of 44 listed fees113.1 lira
DÖSİMM’s share113.1 lira × 83%93.8 lira
SICPA Türkiye’s share113.1 lira × 17%19.2 lira
Invoiced price per earphone53.7 million lira ÷ 200,000268.5 lira
Shortfall per sale268.5 lira − 19.2 lira249.3 lira
Shortfall on 200,000 earphones200,000 × 249.3 lira49.9 million lira

The 19 lira retained by SICPA Türkiye includes VAT. The calculation makes no allowance for labour, software or tax costs. Adding them would increase the shortfall. Even at the highest audio-guide price in the schedule, the company’s share is 34 lira. The earphone costs about eight times that. For the company’s share alone to cover the earphone, the audio guide would have to sell for 1,579 lira.

This calculation rests on three assumptions. First, the 17% share also applies to audio-guide revenue. Second, one earphone is given out with each audio-guide sale. Third, all the earphones were distributed with audio guides sold separately. Ekonomist reported in October 2024 that visitors use the audio guide through the Türkiye’nin Müzeleri app, which they download to their phones. According to the admission price list dated 1 March 2024, where the service is available it is already included in the ticket price for foreign visitors. Our calculation does not include the company’s share of those tickets. If any of the assumptions is wrong, the result changes. SICPA Türkiye’s contract and records would establish the facts.

If the assumptions hold, SICPA Türkiye pays 14 times as much for an earphone as it earns on each audio-guide sale. Is the company knowingly taking a loss on this service? If so, who approved the purchase, and who bears the loss?

The prices in Chinese wholesale listings

The two Caserta Global invoices we have date from August and September 2025. Together they cover 200,000 earphones for about 53.7 million lira.

SICPA Türkiye provides audio guides in museums and may need earphones. A quantity of 200,000 in two months suggests disposable earphones that visitors are given and do not have to return. That is why our comparison uses Chinese sellers’ listings for disposable earphones and earphones for tour-guide systems.

ItemPrice per earphonePrice for 200,000 earphones
SICPA Türkiye invoices, average268.5 lira ($6.55)53.7 million lira
Ear-hook tour-guide earphone, Alibaba$1.40 (57.4 lira)11.5 million lira
Tour-guide system earphone, Alibaba$0.58–$0.85 (23.8–34.9 lira)4.8–7.0 million lira
Disposable earphone, Made-in-China$0.11–$0.18 (4.5–7.4 lira)0.9–1.5 million lira

The exchange rate on 22 August 2025 was 41.01 lira to the dollar (Ziraat Katılım). The prices are the sellers’ asking prices on Alibaba and Made-in-China, retrieved on 18 November 2026. The minimum order in these listings ranges from one to 1,000 units.

The question is the price invoiced for the earphones. How many quotations were obtained? What was the price compared against? Who counted the 200,000 earphones, and who took delivery?

Then there is the boat. LZK Grup billed 4.2 million lira for boat rental. The 2025 list puts LZK’s total at 46.2 million lira, exactly 11 times the boat invoice.

Perhaps the boat carries visitors. The sites SICPA Türkiye serves include the Maiden’s Tower, which is reached by water. Perhaps it serves some other purpose. We do not know. What we do know is that the company that issued the invoice was incorporated in the week that 2025 began.

Three companies, one telephone number

Caserta Global issued the earphone invoices. LZK Grup issued the boat rental invoice. There is also Kozlu Dekor. Three separate company names, three separate invoices and a combined 270.8 million lira in the lists. All the invoices bear the same telephone number.

The connection goes beyond the telephone number. Incorporation notices reviewed by The Ledgers show that Caserta Global has two shareholders, each holding half the company. The same two people each own 5% of LZK Grup. A company called Kozlu Mobilya İnşaat owns the remaining 90%.

We could not verify whether Kozlu Mobilya İnşaat and Kozlu Dekor, the company that issued an invoice, are the same legal entity. We are not naming the shareholders because there is no allegation against them.

LZK has a short history. It appears in the Istanbul Chamber of Commerce’s list of new companies for the week that 2025 began, with registration number 1060573 and an address in Kadıköy. In its first year, the SICPA list recorded 46.2 million lira against its name. In its second, 59.1 million.

The three companies accounted for 44.2 million lira in 2024. In 2025 the figure was 153.3 million lira, about three and a half times as much in one year.

There is one more name, BSE İnşaat. Registry data gives its incorporation date as 1 October 2025. It appears in the 2026 list with 44.3 million lira. Beside its entry is the note “CASERTA GLOBAL İÇ VE DIŞ”. We do not know what the note means, so we excluded BSE from the three-company total. SICPA’s accounting department should know.

There is nothing criminal about doing business with companies that have shareholders in common. Checking whether suppliers are independent of each other is one of the basics of compliance. Did SICPA’s compliance team make that check in Türkiye?

Three groups of recipients, 1.83 billion lira

SICPA Türkiye has run ticket offices at museums and archaeological sites since 2018. Its CEO, Sami Çebi, wrote in December 2024 that it operated at 84 sites. For each year there are two lists, headed “Müze” (Museum) and “TR”. Three groups of recipients stand out.

Recipient2024–2026 total in the lists
Kultura1,220.9 million lira
Mavi Uçak338.1 million lira
Caserta Global, LZK Grup and Kozlu Dekor270.8 million lira
Total1,829.8 million lira

The figures are sums of entries in the lists. The lists contain no transaction dates, payment slips or bank references. We could not verify individual payments against bank records.

The earphone and boat invoices come from the smallest row in that table. The larger rows raise larger questions.

Kultura and Mavi Uçak account for 1.56 billion lira

Kultura and Mavi Uçak are the two largest recipients in the lists.

The entries for Kultura show 269.6 million lira in 2024, 427.8 million in 2025 and 523.5 million so far in 2026. That comes to 1.22 billion lira. An invoice in our possession, dated 27 November 2025, lists “museum labour services” and “recharged labour costs for Denizli”. Its value before VAT is 25.2 million lira.

The Ledgers asked Kultura about its relationship with SICPA. The company replied in writing on 1 November 2026. It did not answer our questions, saying it first wanted to know more about us. It described the company we had asked about in one sentence: “a company with which we have a single, ongoing commercial relationship that will end at the close of the year”.

A single commercial relationship, due to end at year’s end. In the lists it adds up to 1.22 billion lira in three years.

The total for Mavi Uçak is 338.1 million lira: 68.7 million in 2024, 126.8 million in 2025 and 142.6 million in 2026. We have no invoice from the company and do not know what the amounts were for.

We found no shared telephone number for these two recipients. None is needed to ask how two relationships worth 1.56 billion lira came about. How were the contracts awarded, how were prices set and who signed off on delivery of the services?

Red flags

Anti-fraud bodies keep lists of signs that warrant a closer look even though they are no proof of a crime. The European Anti-Fraud Office, OLAF, calls them red flags. A flag indicates that further scrutiny is needed. It does not establish fraud.

The SICPA Türkiye documents show two flags on OLAF’s list.

  • Prices above the market rate. OLAF’s 2017 guide identifies prices significantly above the market average. At SICPA Türkiye, earphones were invoiced at an average of 269 lira each.
  • Links between suppliers. The same guide lists connections between bidders such as common directors, cross-shareholdings, shared addresses and the same telephone number. Caserta Global, LZK Grup and Kozlu Dekor used the same telephone number, and Caserta’s two shareholders also hold stakes in LZK. We do not know whether these companies submitted competing bids.

The records show two further details. Two suppliers were newly incorporated: LZK Grup in the week that 2025 began, and BSE İnşaat on 1 October 2025. And the total for the three companies rose from 44.2 million to 153.3 million lira in a year.

Each of these indicators could have an innocent explanation. SICPA is in a position to give it.

Impeccable on paper

SICPA’s compliance documents read impeccably.

Its Supplier Code of Conduct requires suppliers to disclose any actual or apparent conflict of interest “immediately”. It gives SICPA the right to audit suppliers and end its relationship with those in breach. The company says its anti-bribery system has been certified to ISO 37001 since 2021. There is also a statement by Philippe Amon from the company’s Code of Conduct: complying with the law and conducting business with integrity “is not optional”.

These documents come with a history.

In June 2021, SICPA do Brasil and Ceptis signed a settlement worth about 762 million reais with the Brazilian authorities over improper payments to a public official between 2009 and 2015.

In April 2023 it was Switzerland’s turn. The Office of the Attorney General convicted SICPA SA, imposing a fine of 1 million Swiss francs and a compensatory claim of 80 million francs. Prosecutors said organisational shortcomings had allowed employees to bribe public officials in Brazil, Colombia and Venezuela. Those shortcomings concerned corporate governance, risk management and compliance.

Yes, compliance.

The investigation into the company’s CEO and principal shareholder was closed. SICPA said Amon had been cleared in full. The prosecutors nevertheless ordered him to pay part of the costs of the proceedings and awarded him no compensation.

SICPA did not contest the decision. In its statement, it said it disagreed with the reasoning, described the matter as involving “organisational shortcomings” between 2008 and 2015, and said it had established a robust compliance management system.

Two countries and two hefty bills should have taught this company what compliance means. Did they?

Who stands at the top?

To whom does SICPA’s compliance function report? According to the company’s own website, two people: the CEO and the chair of the Audit Committee.

The CEO is Philippe Amon. The chairman is Philippe Amon. The principal shareholder is Philippe Amon.

At many companies it is usual for the head of compliance to report to the CEO. What distinguishes SICPA is that management, the board and the principal shareholding are all in the hands of the same person. That leaves one counterweight: the Audit Committee.

According to a 2020 corporate announcement, Hermann A. Wirz chaired the committee. Wirz is a former senior finance executive at Nestlé and, according to registry records, remains a member of SICPA Holding’s board. We could not verify whether he still chairs the committee.

Deloitte provides the external link in the chain. The same registry records show that Deloitte SA has been SICPA Holding’s statutory auditor since August 2018. A statutory auditor gives an opinion on the group’s financial statements and does not examine every invoice. We do not know how far that audit covered SICPA Türkiye’s accounts.

At the Turkish end is Sami Çebi, identified in the press as CEO of SICPA Türkiye. We do not know who approved the payments listed. He is the first person to ask.

With so few links in the chain, the questions are straightforward. Did anyone ask about earphones invoiced at an average of 269 lira apiece? Did anyone notice the three suppliers using the same telephone number? If they did, what did they do? If nobody noticed, what was the system designed to detect?

Nine questions for SICPA

Our questions are addressed to Philippe Amon, Sami Çebi, the Audit Committee of SICPA Holding and Deloitte SA.

1. When Caserta Global, LZK Grup and Kozlu Dekor were approved as suppliers, were those approving them aware of the ownership links and the shared telephone number? Was a conflict-of-interest disclosure obtained?

2. How many bids were obtained for work involving these three companies? What were the prices compared against, and who approved the payments?

3. What was the model and country of origin of the 200,000 earphones? How many quotations were considered before the price averaging 269 lira each was selected? Was it compared with the market price?

4. Why were the earphones purchased, to whom were they distributed and who took delivery? What share of audio-guide revenue does SICPA Türkiye retain, and who, given that share, approved the purchase at an average of 269 lira apiece? For what purpose was the boat hired, and for how many months?

5. What does the note “CASERTA GLOBAL İÇ VE DIŞ” beside BSE İnşaat’s entry mean?

6. Which contracts govern the relationships with Kultura and Mavi Uçak, and how were they awarded?

7. Were these supplier relationships in Türkiye reported to the group’s compliance officer? Have SICPA Türkiye’s procurement processes undergone an independent review in the past three years?

8. Has the Audit Committee put the supplier relationships in Türkiye on its agenda? Has it received any finding or tip-off about them?

9. Are SICPA Türkiye’s accounts within the scope of the group audit? Did Deloitte communicate any findings about these supplier relationships to management?

SICPA promises governments it can account for every packet. Let it begin by accounting for the money in its own coffers in Türkiye.

The Ledgers is ready to publish responses from SICPA, Deloitte and the companies named in this report.

What this report is based on

  • Payment lists. Six lists attributed to SICPA Türkiye covering 2024–2026, with 648 entries showing amounts. These are tables compiled after the fact, not bank statements. They contain no transaction dates, payment slips or bank references. It is also unclear whether the amounts include VAT.
  • Invoices. Invoices issued to SICPA Türkiye by Caserta Global, LZK Grup, Kozlu Dekor and Kultura.
  • Incorporation notices and registry records. Incorporation notices for Caserta Global and LZK Grup, records from the Istanbul Chamber of Commerce and a company directory, and the Swiss commercial register.
  • Market price comparison. Wholesale earphone listings on Alibaba and Made-in-China on 18 November 2026, and the dollar exchange rate in Ziraat Katılım’s bulletin for 22 August 2025. Since the earphone model is unknown, the comparison is an estimate. Only itemised invoice and import documents can establish the exact price difference. Dollar equivalents throughout the report use the same exchange rate and are approximate for totals spanning three years.
  • Audio-guide fees. The Ministry of Culture and Tourism’s Electronic Guide System fee schedules, one effective from 1 March 2024 and the other due to take effect on 1 April 2027. We could not verify whether an interim schedule was issued in 2025. We have no document showing how the earphones were distributed to visitors. The 83%–17% revenue split is based on information obtained by The Ledgers. The loss calculation rests on the three assumptions set out in the text.
  • Guide to red flags. OLAF’s 2017 guide to procurement fraud.
  • Official decisions and SICPA’s own documents. The 2023 decision by the Office of the Attorney General of Switzerland and the 2021 settlement in Brazil, as well as SICPA’s Supplier Code of Conduct, compliance programme and statements.

This report makes no allegation of a crime. The headline asks a question. We have found no evidence that the companies or people named in the lists acted unlawfully. We are asking how this money was spent and what oversight there was.

Sources

File updates

  1. First published

    Report published

Share this report
THE LEDGERS / COMMUNITY

Reader comments

Verified members can comment. Comments appear after editorial approval. Please address the evidence and avoid personal information.

No published comments yet.

Sign in / Create account →
Red and black print portrait of Abdulrahman El-Sayed, based on a still from the seriesMichigan, USA

The Ledgers Series

New documentary8 episodes

His Name Is Abdulrahman

What drew a doctor into Michigan politics?

Watch the series