COMPANIES IN FOCUSIn reports and research lists
MAJOR PROGRESS IN THE INVESTMENT FUND INVESTIGATIONREPORT

Money starts coming back in fund fraud probe: 40 billion lira in two months

Justice Minister Akın Gürlek announced on Tuesday evening that 40.4 billion lira had been recovered from 75 people. President Recep Tayyip Erdoğan gave an update in parliament on Wednesday. The recovered money had been transferred to banks, investors had received 161 billion lira and the number of people held in pretrial detention had risen to 136. Fourteen people were remanded in custody on Tuesday, and trustees were appointed to Altınbaş Holding and Adil Katılım Bankası. On Wednesday it emerged that prosecutors had requested permission to investigate Şahap Kavcıoğlu, the former head of Türkiye’s banking regulator.

Share this report
A close-up of Erdoğan’s clenched hand above a lectern, with microphones and the Turkish flag.
A detail of Erdoğan’s hand at a lectern. Landscape crop of an archive photograph shared by Fahrettin Altun on 21 August 2020. · Fahrettin Altun / X — The Ledgers

Justice Minister Akın Gürlek published a long post on X on Tuesday evening. It listed suspects, people in custody and assets seized. The news was in the last line: 75 people, 40.4 billion lira.

In fraud investigations, that is usually the last piece of news to arrive, if it comes at all. Suspects are found and cases go to court, but the money has long since changed hands. In the investment fund investigation, the order has been reversed. The money is coming back while the investigation is still under way.

Gürlek’s figure covers voluntary repayments and money recovered by other means. That works out at roughly 540 million lira per person, or an average of 660 million lira a day since the liquidation order on 17 September.

Speaking at his ruling AK Party’s parliamentary group meeting at noon on Wednesday, President Recep Tayyip Erdoğan explained where the money had gone. He said that about 41 billion lira in illicit gains had been returned and transferred to banks for interim payments.

The recovered money is already with the banks for distribution to investors, rather than sitting in escrow.

What changed in two weeks

A comparison of Gürlek’s 3 November statement with his post on Tuesday evening shows how quickly the investigation is moving.

Indicator3 November17 November
Suspects433498
In pretrial detention112129
Under court-ordered supervision186289
Subject to arrest warrants3854
Individuals whose assets are subject to restrictions359417
Legal entities whose assets are subject to restrictions111149
Amount recoveredAbout 30 billion liraAbout 40.4 billion lira
Fund Coordination Board meetings810

Source: Justice Minister Gürlek’s statements on 3 November and 17 November.

When Gürlek posted, 129 people were in pretrial detention. Seven more were remanded in custody that night, bringing the figure Erdoğan announced on Wednesday to 136.

More than 10 billion lira was recovered in two weeks. Vice President Cevdet Yılmaz said on 14 November that voluntary repayments had reached 33.4 billion lira. Three days later, Gürlek put the figure, including other recoveries, at 40.4 billion.

For a sense of scale, on 9 October Gürlek said that 141 individuals and 73 companies that had each made more than 100 million lira from three groups of funds had made 187.65 billion lira between them. He said the list had been sent to the Savings Deposit Insurance Fund (TMSF) to seek repayment. The amount recovered now exceeds one-fifth of that total.

There was more to Tuesday than the figures. Seven people were remanded in custody in the morning and seven more that night. The TMSF took over the management of Altınbaş Holding and four affiliated companies, as well as four other companies, including Adil Katılım Bankası. Prosecutors said the bank’s capital had been involved in the alleged fund manipulation.

Erdoğan says not a single kuruş came from the public purse

Erdoğan devoted the last part of his speech to the funds and set out the figures.

Of the 455,758 investors in the funds under liquidation, 444,987 have received at least one payment. That is 97 out of every 100. A total of 371,021 people have recovered their entire net investment. Interim payments of up to 1 million lira have been completed across 110 funds.

Payments to date total about 161 billion lira. The president stressed where the money came from, saying the payments had been made “without spending even a single kuruş” from state coffers.

From the first day of the crisis, investors have asked who would foot the bill. Erdoğan’s answer was clear: taxpayers did not. According to an earlier explanation by Vice President Yılmaz, the money comes from assets in the funds under liquidation and from amounts recovered by the TMSF.

Erdoğan said the process was being managed “with a speed and effectiveness beyond comparison with countries that have faced similar problems, and in an extremely transparent manner.”

Erdoğan also reported three further developments. The State Supervisory Council completed its initial review at the beginning of the week. A bill to tighten oversight of capital markets and increase penalties will come before parliament soon, and Erdoğan said he wanted input from the opposition. The search for fugitives continues.

Gürlek says repayment does not end a suspect’s legal exposure

The sentence immediately after the 40.4 billion figure in Gürlek’s post mattered as much as the number itself: “Voluntary repayment does not, on its own, remove legal liability.”

A suspect remains a suspect after paying. What changes is that victims can begin to recoup their losses without waiting for a court ruling.

The minister added a detail as he spoke to reporters on his way into Wednesday’s parliamentary group meeting. The number of people applying to make repayments was growing. “We have applications from prison, too,” he said.

The fact that suspects in custody are also applying to repay money suggests that 40 billion lira will not be the final tally.

Names and party ties carry no exemption

In his Tuesday evening post, Gürlek also set out the standard he said investigators applied. What matters, he wrote, is “concrete evidence and legal liability, not a person’s position, title or connections.”

The names in the case suggest that principle has been put into practice. Those remanded in custody include Fatma Betül Sayan Kaya, a former cabinet minister and former deputy chair of the AK Party. A former deputy chair of the Capital Markets Board, a deputy head of the Banking Regulation and Supervision Agency (BDDK) and a former chief executive of Borsa İstanbul have also been remanded in custody.

On Wednesday it emerged that the case had reached a further level. Prosecutors applied to the Ministry of Treasury and Finance for permission to investigate former BDDK chairman Şahap Kavcıoğlu. Minister Mehmet Şimşek assigned the ministry’s inspectorate to conduct a preliminary review. Kavcıoğlu is a former AK Party member of parliament. Erdoğan appointed him to head first the Central Bank and then the BDDK.

A second example came with Tuesday’s trusteeship order. The companies placed under TMSF management include Adil Katılım Bankası and Adil Varlık Yönetim, both reported to belong to Mustafa Yazıcı, the son of AK Party deputy chair Hayati Yazıcı. An order restricting Mustafa Yazıcı’s assets on 30 September was lifted within hours, leaving a foreign travel ban in place. The bank’s general manager was remanded in custody on 9 November. Seven weeks after the asset restrictions were lifted, management of the bank passed to the TMSF.

Neither example has resulted in a judgment. A request for permission to investigate is not a charge. Kavcıoğlu denies the allegations, and no judicial proceedings have been brought against Hayati Yazıcı. Even so, an investigation that extends from a former deputy chair of the ruling party to the head of a regulator appointed by the president is the clearest indication so far that neither name nor party affiliation confers an exemption.

The investigation has gone beyond fund managers to those responsible for overseeing them. Gürlek wrote that the file also covers allegations about regulatory oversight and the responsibility of public officials. He added a note of caution: no allegation would be presumed true, and no concrete evidence would be ignored.

What remains: 84,000 investors, 75 names and 54 fugitives

There has been substantial progress, and there is still work to do. The Ledgers will track four issues.

First are the investors still owed money. On 14 November Yılmaz said 84,737 people remained in the system, including 10,771 who had received no payment at all. The final interim payment is planned within a week or two. People deemed to have made illicit gains, those with unresolved legal issues and those whose net investment is zero will not receive a payment.

Second are the identities of the 75 people who repaid money. Gürlek says the TMSF has the names and the authorities know who they are, but the list has not been made public. Publishing it would give concrete effect to Erdoğan’s pledge of transparency. It should be released as soon as doing so would no longer compromise the confidentiality of the investigation.

Third are the fugitives and the money still outstanding. The authorities are looking for 54 people under arrest warrants. Recoveries now amount to a fifth of the 187.65 billion lira in gains announced on 9 October. The courts will decide how much of the balance constitutes illicit gains.

Fourth is the timetable. According to press reports citing political insiders, Erdoğan told his party’s Central Executive Board on Monday, “Let’s finish this process by the new year.” The remark has not been officially confirmed. If accurate, it sets a target for liquidation, payments and legislation. The timing of an indictment is for prosecutors to decide, and that of a ruling is for the court.

One development on Tuesday falls outside these figures. The TMSF was appointed trustee of the company behind Sözcü TV and sozcu.com.tr, and orders were issued to take four people into police custody. The chief public prosecutor’s office said the operation was part of an investigation into allegations that the group’s owner, Burak Akbay, belonged to the group known as FETÖ and financed terrorism.

The newspaper appeared the next day with the headline “We fell victim to the funds,” arguing that it had been targeted because of its fund coverage. Gürlek did not answer questions on the matter on Wednesday. Keeping the two cases distinct is in the interests of the fund investigation itself. The evidence in the Sözcü case should be presented with the same clarity.

The Ledgers’ position remains the same: we support every step that follows the money and oppose every step that goes after the reporting.

When will the rest come back?

Two months ago the question was “Where is the money?” Now it is “When will the rest come back?”

Erdoğan described what happened as an organised act of wrongdoing. Those behind it, in his words, “are being held to account, one by one, for the crimes they committed.” Gürlek’s answer lies in the figures themselves.

Forty billion lira is now in the account. We will report on the rest when it arrives.

Editor’s note

This is a news analysis. Sources for figures and quotations are given below. The assessments are those of The Ledgers.

The investigation is ongoing. Everyone named is presumed innocent. Pretrial detention is not a conviction, and voluntary repayment does not constitute an admission of guilt.

Prosecutors have requested permission to investigate Şahap Kavcıoğlu. Permission has not been granted. No judicial action against Hayati Yazıcı or order for Mustafa Yazıcı’s detention or arrest has been reported. The information that Adil Katılım Bankası and Adil Varlık Yönetim belong to Mustafa Yazıcı comes from press reports.

Erdoğan’s remarks are drawn from the accounts published by news agencies and newspapers immediately after his speech. They will be checked against the presidency’s official transcript when it becomes available. The 187.65 billion lira represents the total gains announced on 9 October. The full amount has not been determined by a court to constitute illicit gains. The year-end target comes from reports citing political insiders.

Sources

File updates

  1. First published

    Report published

Share this report
THE LEDGERS / COMMUNITY

Reader comments

Verified members can comment. Comments appear after editorial approval. Please address the evidence and avoid personal information.

No published comments yet.

Sign in / Create account →
Red and black print portrait of Abdulrahman El-Sayed, based on a still from the seriesMichigan, USA

The Ledgers Series

New documentary8 episodes

His Name Is Abdulrahman

What drew a doctor into Michigan politics?

Watch the series